Finding Your Next ‘Chief Digital Officer’ (CDO)

For many retail businesses, the decision to hire a Chief Digital Officer doesn’t come out of nowhere. It usually follows a period of growth, frustration, or both. Online sales might be climbing, but the experience feels disjointed. Stores are trading well, but digital doesn’t quite connect to what’s happening on the shop floor. Or perhaps the technology stack has grown faster than the strategy behind it.

At that point, digital stops being a “department” and starts becoming a leadership conversation. And that’s where the idea of a CDO enters the picture.

But hiring a Chief Digital Officer in retail isn’t straightforward. The title means different things to different businesses, and getting it wrong can be costly. The right CDO can reshape how a brand connects with customers and operates internally. The wrong one can create noise without progress. This is where thoughtful retail executive recruitment really matters.

Why the CDO role looks different in retail

Retail has a habit of borrowing job titles from other sectors and then reshaping them. The CDO role is a good example. In some organisations, it’s heavily ecommerce-led. In others, it’s about data, systems, and transformation. Sometimes it sits alongside marketing. Sometimes it cuts across every function.

What makes retail unique is the need for balance. A successful CDO has to understand digital growth without losing sight of stores, teams, and customers. They need to work with buying, operations, finance, and marketing, not in isolation from them.

That’s why many retailers struggle with this hire. They know they need senior digital leadership, but they’re not always clear on what success actually looks like in their own business.

Before engaging in retail recruitment at this level, clarity is everything.

Getting clear on what you really need

One of the biggest mistakes brands make when hiring a CDO is defaulting to someone who has “done digital” somewhere else, without fully considering context.

Is your priority scaling ecommerce profitably? Integrating digital and store operations? Replacing legacy systems? Improving customer insight and personalisation? Or leading a broader transformation programme?

Each of those requires a different kind of leader.

Some CDOs are builders. They thrive in businesses where the foundations are still being laid. Others are optimisers, brought in to refine, connect, and improve what already exists. Some are change leaders, comfortable challenging long-held ways of working and bringing teams with them.

Being honest about where your business is today will shape the success of your retail executive recruitment process far more than any job description.

Digital leadership is as much about people as platforms

It’s easy to focus on technology when hiring a CDO. Systems, platforms, architecture, and data are all important. But in retail, digital changes lives and dies with people.

A strong CDO understands that transformation doesn’t happen in a vacuum. It happens through collaboration with store teams, head office functions, and senior leadership. It requires influencing peers, not just directing teams.

The best candidates tend to talk less about tools and more about behaviours. They can explain how they’ve brought reluctant stakeholders on a journey, how they’ve translated complex digital concepts into commercial decisions, and how they’ve balanced pace with pragmatism.

These are the qualities that don’t always come through on a CV, but they make all the difference once someone is in the role.

This is why working with a retail recruitment agency that understands those nuances can change the outcome of the hire.

Cultural fit matters more than ever at this level

At executive level, technical capability is only part of the picture. Cultural fit becomes critical, particularly for a role that touches so many areas of the business.

Retail businesses often have deeply ingrained ways of working. Long-standing teams, strong personalities, and a clear sense of identity. A CDO who arrives with a “rip it up and start again” mindset can quickly alienate the very people they need to work with.

Equally, someone who is too cautious may struggle to drive the change the role exists for in the first place.

Finding the balance takes time, honest conversations, and a recruitment process that goes beyond surface-level experience. This is where executive search plays such an important role in retail recruitment, allowing space to explore mindset, values, and leadership style, not just track record.

The internal impact of hiring the right CDO

When the right person is appointed, the impact tends to ripple quickly through the business.

Decision-making becomes clearer because data is more accessible and better understood. Digital initiatives align more closely with commercial goals. Teams start to work together rather than in parallel.

Stores feel less disconnected from online. Marketing gains better insight. Operations benefit from improved visibility. Finance has clearer forecasting and performance metrics.

These outcomes don’t come from technology alone. They come from leadership that understands how retail really works.

Common issues in CDO hiring

There are a few patterns that crop up time and again in unsuccessful hires.

One is over-indexing on sector prestige. A candidate from a high-profile digital business may look impressive, but struggle to adapt to the realities of retail. Another is underestimating the scale of internal change required, leaving the CDO isolated and unsupported.

Sometimes the role itself is overloaded, with unrealistic expectations around timescales and outcomes. Digital transformation is rarely quick, especially in established retail environments.

Being realistic about what can be achieved, and when, sets both the business and the individual up for success.

How a retail recruitment agency adds value here

A Chief Digital Officer hire has long-term consequences, shaping how teams work, how decisions are made, and how the business grows. That’s why many brands choose to work with a retail recruitment agency that specialises in senior appointments, like ourselves at Zachary Daniels.

A strong recruitment partner will challenge assumptions, help refine the brief, and bring insight from similar hires across the sector. They’ll have conversations with candidates who aren’t actively looking but may be open to the right opportunity.

More importantly, they’ll focus on alignment. Between strategy and skillset. Between culture and leadership style. Between ambition and reality.

This approach to retail executive recruitment reduces risk and increases the likelihood of a hire that delivers long-term value.

Supporting the CDO once they join

The work doesn’t stop once the offer is accepted. Onboarding a CDO properly is just as important as selecting them.

Clear priorities, access to stakeholders, and visible support from the wider leadership team all make a difference. So does giving the individual space to listen and learn before pushing for immediate change.

Retail brands that invest time here tend to see better outcomes and stronger retention.

Thinking long-term about digital leadership

For some brands, the CDO role is a stepping stone. Over time, digital capability becomes embedded across the business, and responsibility shifts. For others, it remains a core executive position.

There’s no single right answer. What matters is being intentional about why the role exists and how it evolves.

As retail continues to change, digital leadership will only become more important. But success will always come back to people, not platforms.

Having the right conversation

If your brand is considering hiring a Chief Digital Officer, it’s worth slowing the process down before speeding it up. Ask the difficult questions early. Be clear on what success looks like. And think carefully about who will thrive in your environment, not just who looks good on paper.

Retail recruitment at this level is as much about judgment as it is about process.

If you’re starting to think about what a CDO might mean for your business, talk to us. Early conversations around retail executive recruitment often make the difference between a role that sounds right and a hire that truly delivers.